Authored by Vaishnavi Rathore 

Asha’s husband did not believe her initially. Neither did most of her neighbours in Pichompa Kalan, Haryana. An orchard of citrus fruits, mangoes, watermelons, amla, jamun, apricot, pulses and cereals—how could that grow given the limited productivity of red and clayey soil of the region?

But for the last 10 years, Asha, with help from her family as well as hired labour has been growing all of that and more. And the trademark of these—they have been grown with chemical-free inputs. This is akin to what Nirmala Sitharaman, the Finance Minister in her speech of Budget 2019-2020 mentioned when she said, “We shall go back to basics on one count: Zero Budget Farming.” This type of farming emphasises on elimination of chemical pesticides, sustaining agriculture with eco-friendly processes, and restoring soil fertility and organic matter.

Asha's produce
From Asha’s Farm– Top (right to left) Bajra, a grape vine at her home, moong dal Below (right to left) keenu, a mango tree, lemons

How Is This Different?

About 25 kilometers from the district headquarters of Haryana’s Charkhi-Dadri, Pichompa Kalan is home to about 3,200 people. A negligible number of them practice chemical-free farming. Amongst them are Asha and her daughter-in-law, Jyoti, who spend time every morning and evening in their 3 killa (3 acres) of land, pulling out unwanted weeds. The trees of lemons, oranges, sweetlimes are interspersed with vegetables like spinach, methi (fenugreek), and pulses like chana (gram), bajra (pearl millet), and wheat. She is also currently experimenting with custard apples within the same fields. Intercropping is considered to be an important aspect of Zero-budget farming.

Asha and family
Asha’s daughter-in-law Jyoti taking out weeds from vegetable saplings

The farms also require constant attention; one attack by pests is enough to ruin the entire crop. To avert pests from attacking, Asha resorts to a spray made of buttermilk, which is kept in a mud pot immersed in cowdung for about 3 months. Another method to keep the pests away is to burn guggal, a resin available from trees. “Our grandmothers used to prescribe this method of burning guggal during the flowering stage,” she says.

To increase the fertility of the soil, she uses jeevamrut which is a concoction of cow dung, cow urine, gram flour, and jaggery with water after letting it prepare for the same duration. She adds this to the soil once every two months. For the same purpose, she also prepared vermi-compost. Everything that Asha needs as manure, and to keep the pests away is available at home. Her expenditure on inputs then, is almost zero. “This type of farming may have low investment, but requires a lot more hard work and labour,” Jyoti adds. 

organic pesticides
(L) Jeevamrut being prepared, (R ) Buttermilk in earthen pots dug in cowdung

Like most of the farmers in the village, Asha too depends on her tube well for irrigation, but with a variation. The economic survey 2018-19 claimed that 89% of groundwater extracted in the country is used for irrigation, and it further suggested that the focus should shift to irrigation water productivity from land productivity and thrust should be on micro-irrigation. Zero budget farming also calls for water-efficiency. Asha and team thus, have been practicing sprinkler and drip irrigation.

drip
Pipes for drip irrigation hanging idle when not in use

In her budget speech, Nirmala Sitharaman had gone ahead to say, “Steps such as this can help in doubling our farmers’ income in time for our 75th year of Independence.” While Asha’s land gives her a variety of organic produce, if it can really double a farmer’s income, or can be scaled-up are questions without an easy answer.

The initial shift

In the early years of the farm, a labourer had quit because he did not believe that the farm could grow without use of DAP and urea. Jyoti Awasthi, the Founder Director of Satat Sampada, a social enterprise to promote organic farming also noticed the same while working with farmers in Uttar Pradesh. “They were absolutely unsure about working without fertilizers, DAP and urea,” she says. “They have really lost the trust that agriculture can happen without these.”

The initial 2 years of gestation period, which is the time taken for a farmer to shift to zero-chemical farming and for their soil to be completely free of chemicals, is a challenging time. For these first two years, since the soil takes time to respond to the shift from chemical inputs to organic ones, the produce falls lower–sometimes as low as 40% of what the farmer was receiving with the conventional farming methods. Needless to say, many farmers drop out during this phase.

Asha began her organic farm as a hobby. For those who are dependent on agriculture for their livelihoods, the initial years of lower productivity, the risks of a pest attack and the high requirement of labor are costs that they simply cannot afford.  

In Uttar Pradesh, when Awasthi showed farmers the chemical-free produce of her own 8 acres of demonstration plot, they looked at the quality of the soil and the grain and exclaimed, “This is so beautiful, ours is not as good.” Slow confidence building, and hand-holding through the process allowed for the adoption of change. 

Asha fields
Asha’s orchard of fruits and the neighbouring farmlands of the village.

Since they eat what they grow, Awasthi saw that farmers were now beginning to understand the importance of family health, apart from the fact that chemical-free farming allowed for sustained fertility of the soil. When people around Asha started questioning the use of such a practice which is not bringing any profits, she showed them a different type of profit: nests built by birds in her orchard’s trees. Excited about the species of birds that visit her farm, she has also been conscious of the delicate inter linkages that exist in the agriculture ecology. Apart from shift to organic farming as a livelihood option, both Asha and farmers from UP have found a more personal resonation.

 Missing Market 

Mera sona peetal ke daam par jaa raha hai (What is as valuable as gold is being sold at prices of brass),” Asha says. “The selling price of our products are higher, and they have very few takers in the village. It will sell in the cities, but we have not been able to figure out a transportation system for that. There is no market mechanism available.”

Awasthi decided to fill this gap. Her team created an e-commerce platform, Eat Right Basket, to sell organic cereals and vegetables that their network of farmers in Uttar Pradesh grows. “From the very beginning, we involve them in the prices of the produce, the transport system. This ensures that they are a part of the process.”

Even from a small village called Talbehat in Uttar Pradesh, farmers have signed contracts and vegetables are transported every day from Jhansi’s Railway Station to Nizammudin Railway Station in Delhi. “Unless there is a guarantee that their produce will be sold, there isn’t really any incentives to produce chemical-free vegetables.”  This is possibly one of the reasons as to why 1,63,034 farmers of the total cultivators in India are practicing Zero-budget farming, a proportion which is only about 0.1%. 

Tackling Unawareness

Asha had helped her neighbour convert 1 kila of land into organic farming. Following that, they applied for organic certification by the government. But when no one came to test the soil for a long time, they did not know who to approach for further communication. Soon, they shifted back to their chemicals.

“No one in the village has much knowledge of the processes under organic farming, even the Sarpanch does not know.” Awasthi reinforces that even when the government has announced schemes for supporting this type of farming, it has not reached the grass-roots.

Asha
Asha standing against her trees of Kinoo

Asha has been an avid reader and learner, and has been using YouTube and news to update herself on processes of chemical-free farming. With that, in the past ten years, she has also been able to take benefits from the National Horticulture Mission. This government scheme provides financial assistance like setting up vermi-compost production units at 50% of the cost, and even got her subsidies on installing the drip irrigation system. Others in the area have not been made aware of such benefits. 

For the purpose of knowledge sharing and keeping a check on each other, a few like-minded farmers from the region have created small groups. With about 5 organic farmers in one group, they visit each other’s fields to ensure that no chemicals are being used. They have occasional meetings and discussions, and hope to inspire more people to shift to chemical-free farming.

Creating an Ecosystem

For a shift to take place, Awasthi believes that it is important to set a whole ecosystem for the shift. “Announcing schemes and budget allocations are only a part of the ecosystem,” she says. The rest of the ecosystem requires platforms to sell products, awareness of processes and trainings, constant hand holding, and support from the government in the face of risks.

However, with the government announcing schemes on the same, Awasthi has started observing something interesting—when it comes to organic farming, at least government officials are willing to support their initiatives. “When we have a conversation at the block level, or at the Krishi Vigyan Kendras, there is no longer a denial that organic farming gives results, since the government also has to now collect and produce data in this sector,” she says. “It has given us a high moral ground to work upon.”

But apart from that, the announcement for a shift seems to be a feel-good decision, but largely hollow, and scaling up of such initiatives it still doubtful. It will then be taken up by only a few like Asha, who initiate such shifts out of a love for the practice. “Duniye mei aye aur baag-bagiche na lagaye toh kya fayeda? (Coming into this world and not planting orchards and gardens, then what’s the point?)” she says. The rest, like her neighbours, may not adopt the practice with the same enthusiasm.

This piece is co-published by The Bastion and Mongabay-India

5 COMMENTS

  1. 1. Mr. Palekar is the only person who says that using a vermicompost makes it non-ZBNF. This is not to diss Mr. Palekar’s efforts. What he has been able to do is great, and I do not think the article at any point raises questions at his efforts. Like you said, little knowledge is a dangerous thing, I would ask you to please read more on Agro-ecology, which give a holistic understanding of it all. I can help you with some material, if you need. Moreover, her vermicompost is not “bought”. She makes this in her own farm.
    2) It is great that the farmers you visited said that they didnt have any problem in the shift. But my point is about THIS particular story, and THIS particular person, who had issues. So i do not understand what your point of contention is.
    3)I have barely mentioned any pest-controlling mechanisms in the piece, apart from the spray that is made of fermented buttermilk. Is your point that I havent mentioned it? Because like that i can help you make a list of things that i have not written about, because i do not think its important in the story, or misses something from the story.
    4) Yes, maybe the farmers that YOU visited are earning good profits. But this is MY story of a farmer that I visited. This is about HER. Why she isnt getting profits, I have mentioned it, and i also mentioned in the last comment that you deleted.
    Also, like i said earlier, ZBNF is a PART of organic farming. Yes, I understand that Mr. Palekar believes that it is different, but maybe you would benefit from reading more on agroecology too.
    I do not understand why you think that I am deterring farmers from practicing ZBNF. I have just pointed out the problems that seem to exist currently, so that farmers who are interested to switch, can do so while keeping in mind these things so that they can overcome them while practicing.
    Also, since you seem to feel strongly for this issue, I would invite you to write a short piece on this, and we would love to have your opinion placed next to mine on ZBNF–maybe then you would believe that we care for democratic voices? 🙂
    -Vaishnavi

  2. This looks like a propaganda piece, more than anything else! If the attempt of the writer was to describe Zero Budget Natural Farming, then she’s way off mark. The article heading is misleading, the content is extremely misleading. She has not understood facts at all. In fact, I came across this article, as it was being misused by some vested interests to deride Zero Budget Natural Farming. Thus proving the point that ‘a little knowledge is a dangerous thing!’.

    To correct some of the factual mistakes in the article:
    1) If a farm is using vermicompost, it is not a ZBNF farm. ZBNF avoids all ready composts. It only promotes ‘MULCH’ and multicropping, to restore the ecosystem, it is an agroecology practice.
    2) I have visited many ZBNF farms, all farmers said their migration to ZBNF was immediate. There was no drop in productivity of their farms, and all this talk of long migration times is misleading. Very often, writers confuse ZBNF with certified organic farming practice, and thats why they get it wrong.
    3) The article shows no understanding of pest management practices under ZBNF. While a restored ecosystem will have less problems of pest and weeds, there are some interventions followed by ZBNF during the transformation period.
    4) Profitability: This point is where the author has got it absolutely wrong. Firstly, Subhash Palekar advises farmers, that since they incur little to no expenditure while employing ZBNF, every paisa earned is a profit, so they should stop their conventional calculations. They don’t have to be greedy. They can sell at whatever market prices exist, and yet they would be more profitable than before. The farmers that face a problem are the ones that dont employ ZBNF, but other organic farming methods, and incur huge costs for manure, etc., and then they suffer losses if they don’t get higher prices.

    All in all, its a confused and misleading article, that does more harm than good for the understanding of Zero Budget Natural Farming.

    And lends itself to be misused by people who want to prevent farmers from using such natural methods of farming.

  3. I don’t doubt the intent of the writer, but If the attempt of the writer was to describe Zero Budget Natural Farming, then she’s way off mark. The article heading is misleading, the content is extremely misleading. She has not understood facts at all. In fact, I came across this article, as it was being misused by some vested interests to deride Zero Budget Natural Farming. Thus proving the point that ‘a little knowledge is a dangerous thing!’.

    To correct some of the factual mistakes in the article:
    1) If a farm is using vermicompost, it is not a ZBNF farm. ZBNF avoids all ready composts. It only promotes ‘MULCH’ and multicropping, to restore the ecosystem, it is an agroecology practice.
    2) I have visited many ZBNF farms, all farmers said their migration to ZBNF was immediate. There was no drop in productivity of their farms, and all this talk of long migration times is misleading. Very often, writers confuse ZBNF with certified organic farming practice, and thats why they get it wrong.
    3) The article shows no understanding of pest management practices under ZBNF. While a restored ecosystem will have less problems of pest and weeds, there are some interventions followed by ZBNF during the transformation period.
    4) Profitability: This point is where the author has got it absolutely wrong. Firstly, Subhash Palekar advises farmers, that since they incur little to no expenditure while employing ZBNF, every paisa earned is a profit, so they should stop their conventional calculations. They don’t have to be greedy. They can sell at whatever market prices exist, and yet they would be more profitable than before. The farmers that face a problem are the ones that dont employ ZBNF, but other organic farming methods, and incur huge costs for manure, etc., and then they suffer losses if they don’t get higher prices.

    All in all, its a confused and misleading article, that does more harm than good for the understanding of Zero Budget Natural Farming.

    And lends itself to be misused by people who want to prevent farmers from using such natural methods of farming.

  4. 1,60,000+ organic farmers in India is a good sign!! Yes it will take time but that’s a promise of a lifetime. Those who have seen the damages of conventional farming quickly learn and understand the benefits of zero budget farming viz. economical, health benefits, ecological n also good will. We will scale up eventually. At least there is hope and plenty to improve in this agri space. Kudos to the pioneers! ?

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.